The Perils of Playing Nice with a Narcissist
How Being Kind is Like Handing Them a Loaded Weapon
Ah, niceness. The social lubricant that makes the world a more tolerable place. The thing our mamas drilled into us since we were old enough to string words together. “Be nice!” “Kill ’em with kindness!” “Treat others how you want to be treated!”
And you know what? That’s solid advice — when you’re dealing with normal, emotionally functional human beings. But when it comes to narcissists? Honey, being nice to them is like tossing a live grenade into your own lap and hoping for a confetti explosion instead.
If you aren’t yet a friend of Medium, you can read this article HERE.
The Niceness Trap: Why We Think It’ll Work
We good-hearted, empathetic folks believe in the power of kindness. We think that if we’re patient, understanding, and endlessly forgiving, we’ll eventually break through that ironclad wall of narcissistic dysfunction. We assume they’ll see our kindness, appreciate our unwavering support, and — brace yourself — change.
But here’s the kicker: narcissists don’t see our kindness as a gift. They see it as a vulnerability. A flaw. A neon sign that says, “Push here for unlimited benefits!”
In their twisted little world, kindness doesn’t equate to respect. It equates to control. To them, being nice isn’t a way to build a bridge — it’s a way to construct a cage. And guess who ends up locked inside? (Hint: It’s not them.)
This video really resonated with me on this topic. As genuinely nice people, it is hard to wrap our brains around people who just AREN’T. This helped me to better accept this fact of life.
How Niceness Becomes a Weapon Against You
They Mistake Kindness for Weakness
A narcissist doesn’t look at your generosity and think, “Wow, what a beautiful soul!” They think, “Excellent. A willing servant!” The more you give, the more they expect. They view every kind act as a confirmation that they are entitled to your time, energy, and resources. And when you finally snap and say “enough is enough”? Well, suddenly you’re “selfish” and “ungrateful.” Cute, right?
2. They Use Guilt as a Control Tactic
When you’re nice, you open the door for the narcissist to manipulate you through guilt. They become expert storytellers, spinning tales of their suffering, their victimhood, their woe-is-me existence. And because you’re kind-hearted, you buy into it. You feel bad for them. And what do you do when you feel bad? You do more for them.
Meanwhile, do they reciprocate? Do they suddenly become more loving, giving, or appreciative? Hah! No. They just double down on the guilt-tripping, ensuring that you stay hooked on the idea that if you could just be nicer, everything would finally be okay. Spoiler alert: It won’t.
3. They Exploit Your Obligation Reflex
Narcissists are like master chess players when it comes to obligation. They’ll take a single kind gesture and turn it into a life sentence of servitude.
“I mean, after everything I’ve done for you, you’re really going to say no?”
“I thought you were different! I thought you actually cared about me.”
“Wow, I guess I just can’t count on you for anything.”
Sound familiar? That’s the narcissist playing the obligation card like a Vegas high roller. And because you’re nice, you take the bait. Again. And again. And again.
The Contempt Factor: Why Being Nice Breeds More Abuse
Here’s the sickest part of all: The more you bend over backward to be nice, the less they respect you.
In a healthy relationship, kindness fosters love and mutual appreciation. In a relationship with a narcissist, kindness fosters contempt. Why? Because in their eyes, if you were strong, if you had value, if you were worthy — you wouldn’t be putting up with their crap.
Twisted, isn’t it? They push your limits, take all they can get, and then look at you like, “Pfft. Pathetic.”
It’s a vicious cycle. You try harder to be nice, thinking it’ll bring peace. They take more, lose more respect for you, and treat you worse. And before you know it, you’re drowning in a sea of one-sided effort while they sit comfortably on their throne of entitlement, sipping a metaphorical margarita.
Breaking the Cycle: How to Take Back Your Power
Recognize That Niceness Won’t Fix Them
Being kind to a narcissist is like watering a plastic plant. No matter how much effort you put in, it’s never going to grow. The sooner you accept that, the sooner you can redirect your energy toward yourself — where it actually belongs.
2. Establish (and Enforce) Boundaries
You have the right to say no. You have the right to protect your peace. And if the narcissist throws a tantrum because you’re no longer rolling out the red carpet of endless favors? Let them. Their discomfort is not your emergency.
3. Detach from Their Opinions
The narcissist will call you selfish, heartless, and cruel the moment you stop serving their needs. Let them. Their words don’t define you. Your worth isn’t measured by how much abuse you can tolerate.
4. Prioritize Your Own Well-Being
Imagine if all the love, patience, and kindness you poured into the narcissist was redirected to you. Picture the peace, the happiness, the freedom. You don’t owe them your life force. Use that energy to build the life you deserve.
Final Thoughts: Niceness Isn’t the Problem — It’s Who You’re Being Nice To
Let’s be clear: Kindness is not a weakness. Compassion is not a flaw. You are not wrong for being a loving, giving person. The problem isn’t that you’re nice — it’s that you’ve been nice to someone who weaponizes it against you.
The real flex? Learning when to withhold that niceness. Learning that not everyone is worthy of your goodness. Learning that protecting yourself isn’t cruelty — it’s self-respect.
So go ahead — be kind. But be kind to yourself first. And if the narcissist in your life has a problem with that? Well, they can take it up with their therapist. (Oh wait, they’d have to admit fault for that to happen. Never mind.)
You’ve got this, love. Time to reclaim your power.
Join the Radiant Souls Newsletter!
Snark. Sass. Inspiration. And (Mostly) Helpful Tips & Recipes!
You’re fabulous, but let’s be honest — life can be a hot mess express. That’s where I come in. Sign up for my weekly(ish) newsletter, packed with just the right amount of snark, sass, and straight-up inspiration to keep you feeling empowered, laughing through the chaos, and maybe even whipping up a recipe that won’t set off the smoke alarm.